Главное меню
Мы солидарны с Украиной. Узнайте здесь, как можно поддержать Украину.

Affixation.

Автор Rezia, декабря 6, 2005, 23:56

0 Пользователи и 1 гость просматривают эту тему.

Rezia

There are languages that express grammatical relations by suffixes (languages of the Turkic  and Finno-Ugric families) or by prefixes (some languages of Niger-Congo). The question is: what way is more productive, the usage of suffixes or prefixes? What is there in the nature of languages that makes them prefer one way or the other?
"Сон налягає. Кладе м'якеньку лапу на очі і на лице і шепче до вуха: спи..." (Коцюбинський)
"Ахаль çеç-им шурă юрĕ çав каç ÿкрĕ çĕр çине?" (чăваш юрри)
"Гэта не без гэтага" (з аднаго беларускага рамана)
"ნახევარი პური, ნახევარი ხარჩო"
"If you want to win the fight, say "I believe!" " (Eric)

Elik

Dear Rezia,
it is one of the fundamental issues of the lingvogenesis. If anyone could answer your question, we would be able to trace the development of the human language to its earliest stages.

IMHO, there it is a so-called convergence phenomenon. Most human languages tend to create suffixes and prefixes on their own. Probably, this is the most natural way of language development. As most biological species have developed eyes and blood circulation, so most human languages developed suffixes and prefixes.

Rezia

Цитата: Elik от декабря  7, 2005, 06:53
Dear Rezia,
it is one of the fundamental issues of the lingvogenesis. If anyone could answer your question, we would be able to trace the development of the human language to its earliest stages.

IMHO, there it is a so-called convergence phenomenon. Most human languages tend to create suffixes and prefixes on their own. Probably, this is the most natural way of language development. As most biological species have developed eyes and blood circulation, so most human languages developed suffixes and prefixes.

Dear Elik, thank you for your reply. Could you comment what is meant by convergence here?
"Сон налягає. Кладе м'якеньку лапу на очі і на лице і шепче до вуха: спи..." (Коцюбинський)
"Ахаль çеç-им шурă юрĕ çав каç ÿкрĕ çĕр çине?" (чăваш юрри)
"Гэта не без гэтага" (з аднаго беларускага рамана)
"ნახევარი პური, ნახევარი ხარჩო"
"If you want to win the fight, say "I believe!" " (Eric)

Toman

As follows from the biological example, I think, convergence means here the same as it does in biology - that different languages absolutely independently evolved to give some very similar features - of both similar function and similar view. But nothing about the reasons of such a tendency - maybe, and even most probably (as in biology :) ) it's one of several (or even the only) choices possible, maybe, one of the fastest(simplest) ways, maybe even, no reasons really, only an occasion. But the latter case cannot be accepted, of course, for the most of languages (or species).
Во́зле до́ма хо́лм с куля́ми - вы́йду на́ холм, ку́ль поставлю.
В славном городе Miami тётки мерялись ногтями, тик иң озын завсегда у Фиделя борода!

Быстрый ответ

Обратите внимание: данное сообщение не будет отображаться, пока модератор не одобрит его.

Имя:
Имейл:
Проверка:
Оставьте это поле пустым:
Наберите символы, которые изображены на картинке
Прослушать / Запросить другое изображение

Наберите символы, которые изображены на картинке:

√36:
ALT+S — отправить
ALT+P — предварительный просмотр